8.4: Social and Community Context
By the end of this section, you should be able to:
- Describe the impact of civic participation on individual health.
- Define discrimination and discuss its impact on the social determinants of health.
- Explain how incarceration is linked to the other social determinants of health.
- Discuss the importance of social capital and cohesion in relation to health outcomes.
The social and community context determinant of health includes civic participation, discrimination, incarceration , and social cohesion. Because relationships with family, friends, colleagues, and neighbors greatly impact health and well-being, Healthy People 2030 focuses on increasing social and community support (ODPHP, 2020f). Positive relationships help buffer the negative effects of unsafe neighborhoods, discrimination, and poverty and, by extension, improve overall health and well-being (ODPHP, 2020f).
Civic Participation
Civic participation refers to a range of activities that benefit the community and provide health benefits for participants (APA, 2023). Civic participation helps build social capital , the value gained from having positive interactions and connections between people that enables the community to function effectively and collaboratively in problem-solving efforts. It is these relationships and networks that support the neighborhood and community. By building social capital via civic engagement, members of civic groups are more likely to be physically active and to engage in meaningful activities, providing a sense of purpose (ODPHP, 2020g). Examples include volunteering at community parks, nature reserves, senior centers, community centers, and adult day centers. It can also include civic engagement in the form of environmentalism, education, recycling efforts, composting, farming, and community gardening. Overall, volunteers experience increased psychological well-being and emotional health (ODPHP, 2020g), and adult volunteers aged 60 and above have a lower risk of cognitive impairment (Infurna et al., 2016). Community gardening is associated with increased neighborhood pride, motivation to be involved, and access to healthy foods (Figure 8.5) (ODPHP, 2020g). Group membership has also been found to increase social capital and benefit members by increasing opportunities for social gatherings. Groups such as the Lions Club, Girl Scouts, and Rotary International clubs can be formal, and there can be informal groups, such as book clubs and walking groups (ODPHP, 2020g). Ultimately, individuals and families who are active in their community and have connections with other individuals in their community are happier and healthier.
Discrimination
As discussed in Structural Racism and Systemic Inequities, discrimination refers to unfair treatment of individuals and groups based on certain characteristics such as race , ethnicity , gender , age , religion , sexual orientation , and ability (ODPHP, 2020h). It assigns value based on the social interpretation of how one looks or acts, and it manifests in social actions aimed at protecting more privileged groups at the expense of less privileged ones (ODPHP, 2020h). Discrimination is prevalent in the United States, where 63 percent of adults report experiencing discrimination every day, impacting a variety of population groups, such as older adults, certain ethnic and racial groups, individuals identifying as lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender, and queer/questioning, (LGBTQ), and individuals experiencing disabilities (ODPHP, 2020h). Discrimination is a public health threat. It can precede stress-related emotional, physical, and behavioral changes, resulting in adverse health outcomes across the age spectrum (APA, 2022). These adverse health outcomes include tachycardia, anxiety, hypertension, and gastrointestinal ulcers that lead to negative long-term health outcomes over time. Caring for Vulnerable Populations and Communities discusses the effects of discrimination on health outcomes in more detail.
Discrimination occurs at both the individual and structural levels. Structural discrimination refers to institutional policies, systems, laws, and practices that limit individuals’ and populations’ opportunities, resources, and power based on race, ethnicity, gender, ability, SES, and religion. These deeply rooted practices and beliefs propagate pervasive unjust treatment and oppression of individuals (Braveman et al., 2022).
Discrimination based on race has been linked to significant disparities in health outcomes, attributed to the cumulative effects of racism on the body. Structural racism in health care often results in Black clients receiving poorer-quality care. The 2019 National Healthcare Disparities Report found that White clients receive a better quality of care than almost 41 percent of Black clients (Taylor et al., 2019). In 2018, non-Hispanic Black infants in the United States had 2.4 times the infant mortality rate of White infants (USDHHS Office of Minority Health, 2021). This disparity is rooted in racism; structural racism has resulted in Black women receiving poorer-quality care. On an individual level, the stress from enduring discrimination and racism is cumulative and triggers biological processes that places these women at higher risk for pregnancy-related complications such as preeclampsia, eclampsia, embolisms, and mental health related issues (Taylor et al., 2019). Structural Racism and Systemic Inequities discusses race-based structural discrimination in more detail.
This animation defines intersectionality and explores the reasons why common approaches of addressing discrimination fall short in addressing all the negative factors that may hinder an individual’s well-being.
Watch the video, and then respond to the following questions.
- How would you explain intersectionality?
- How can the nurse apply the concept of intersectionality in community health nursing?
- Can you think of any client encounters from clinical or work experiences where you witnessed the intersection of multiple forms of discrimination at one time? How did this make you feel?
Incarceration
Incarceration refers to confinement in a prison or a jail. Incarceration affects the health of those incarcerated and their families and communities. BIPOC communities and individuals with lower levels of education are disproportionately affected by higher incarceration rates due to the federal policies of the 1960s and 1970s resulting in increased police surveillance and mass incarceration . As of 2018, Black Americans were incarcerated at more than five times the rate of White Americans (Gramlich, 2020). That year, Black Americans represented approximately 12 percent of the U.S. adult population, yet they represented 33 percent of the incarcerated population, while White Americans represented 63 percent of the U.S. adult population and comprised 30 percent of the incarcerated population (Gramlich, 2020). During this same time period, Hispanic Americans represented 16 percent of the U.S. adult population but accounted for 23 percent of the incarcerated population (Gramlich, 2020). Data indicates that White men without a high school diploma or General Education Development (GED) equivalent have a significantly higher risk of being incarcerated (1 in 8) when compared to their more educated peers (1 in 57) (ODPHP, 2020i). Communities with higher rates of poverty and unemployment are disproportionately burdened by higher incarceration and recidivism (being arrested or incarcerated again) rates (ODPHP, 2020i). Structural Racism and Systemic Inequities and Caring Across Practice Settings discuss issues related to incarceration in more detail.
Individuals with a history of incarceration have been found to have worse physical and mental health compared to the general population. Women in this demographic are more likely to have experienced ACEs than women not in the criminal justice system, illustrating how early childhood experiences place certain individuals at higher risk for adverse life outcomes (ODPHP, 2020i). Individuals who have experienced incarceration have higher rates of mental health disorders, hypertension, asthma, cancer, arthritis, tuberculosis, hepatitis C, and HIV (ODPHP, 2020i). This heavy disease burden has implications for when these individuals reenter the community. Already at a financial disadvantage, they may have trouble finding employment and a place to live given their criminal record and lack the resources to seek the medical care needed to manage their conditions. This reinforces the cycle of poverty and poor health outcomes. The United States releases millions of individuals from jail and prison each year, yet recidivism is fairly common, as more than 50 percent of individuals are incarcerated again within 3 years of their initial release. This may be due to the obstacles these individuals face when reentering society (ODPHP, 2020i).
Incarceration often negatively impacts the families of those individuals who are incarcerated. Almost half of incarcerated individuals have minor children, about 19 percent of whom are age 4 or younger (Wang, 2022). Having a parent incarcerated is considered an ACE because it places these children at higher risk for cognitive and health-related challenges throughout their lives and because they are more likely to live in poverty and be homeless (ODPHP, 2022i). These children have higher rates of developmental delays, learning difficulties, speech and language issues, attention disorders, and aggressive behaviors, and they are up to five times more likely to be involved with the criminal justice system than children without incarcerated parents (ODPHP, 2020i). Illustrating the generational effects of parental incarceration as an ACE, many incarcerated parents also grew up in challenging situations:
- 17 percent spent time in foster care.
- 43 percent are from families that received public assistance.
- 19 percent lived in public housing before the age of 18.
- 11 percent were homeless at one point before the age of 18.
- 32 percent had or currently have an incarcerated parent (Wang, 2022).
Community and public health nurses have a role in identifying children who are at risk due to parental incarceration. After identification, nurses can begin a targeted approach to secure access to resources and educational programs aimed at supporting these children and their caregivers. This involves an interprofessional team of school nurses, guidance counselors, and therapists and early childhood educational programs for those that qualify. Community and public health nurses can collaborate with the justice system to advocate for programs such as drug treatment courts to help keep individuals out of prison while treating their addiction (ODPHP, 2020i). Correctional nurses can provide and advocate for comprehensive health services during incarceration to address the individual’s holistic needs (ODPHP, 2020i; see Caring Across Practice Settings) . Community nurses can help individuals who reenter the community access health care, employment resources, food, and housing.
Social Cohesion
Social cohesion refers to the strengths of relationships within a community (ODPHP, 2020j). An indicator of social cohesion is the amount of social capital within a community. Places of worship, community centers, libraries, and families are common sources of social capital. Collective efficacy is another aspect of social cohesion and is based on trust. It refers to a community’s ability to create change and influence behavior through social norms (ODPHP, 2020j). This is associated with improved self-rated health, lower rates of neighborhood violence, and improved access to medical care, healthy food, and places to exercise (Matsaganis & Wilkin, 2015).
Research has demonstrated that high levels of social support positively influence health outcomes such as healthier eating habits, exercise, and even dealing with stress (ODPHP, 2020j). For example, social support contributes to lower atherosclerosis levels (Shah et al., 2021) and is a protective barrier to the harmful consequences of discrimination for many first-generation immigrants (Szaflarski & Bauldry, 2019). Many studies have linked social isolation to detrimental health effects and increased overall mortality , especially in older adults (ODPHP, 2020j). The CDC considers loneliness and social isolation in older adults a significant public health threat, with almost one quarter of adults ages 65 and older considered socially isolated (CDC, 2019). Social isolation also disproportionately affects vulnerable populations, including immigrants and lesbian, gay, bisexual, and transgender (LGBT) populations (CDC, 2019). Social isolation and loneliness are associated with the following health outcomes (CDC, 2019):
- 50 percent increased risk of dementia
- 29 percent increased risk of heart disease
- 32 percent increased risk of stroke
- Higher rates of depression, anxiety, and suicide
Social networks are foundational to a healthy and thriving community. They create social cohesion, can spread positive health behaviors, and give a sense of community to individuals and families (ODPHP, 2020j). Community and public health nurses are well positioned to foster the development of social networks, especially in vulnerable populations. Through senior centers, councils on aging, ethnic centers, local Boys and Girls Clubs, local Y clubs (formerly known as the YMCA), libraries, local government offices, and assisted living facilities, community health nurses can nurture the development of community groups and events (Figure 8.6). By helping to develop programming to refer at-risk individuals and families to existing programs, nurses can make an impact.
The University of Wisconsin Population Health Institute, with the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation’s support, has conceptualized a population health model illustrating a broad vision for health, demonstrating how policies and programs shape a community’s health and outcomes, both quantity and quality of life. This video highlights this model, showing all the factors that impact health (the SDOH) and demonstrating that upstream interventions can be implemented at the population health level to ensure that each individual and community thrives.
Watch the video, and then respond to the following questions.
- What are your impressions of this model?
- Do you feel the model is an accurate representation of the intersection of health and social, economic, and environmental factors? Why or why not?
- How might one use this model in population health nursing?